“You can’t win a race by committee,” Carroll Shelby growled, confronting Ford’s executives in the 2019 film Ford v Ferrari. Cut to driver Ken Miles hammering around the track, his GT40 covered with taped-on strings that chaotically reveal airflow in real time. Shelby’s vision: Real-world performance shreds theoretical perfection every single time.
Ford v Ferrari dramatizes a classic showdown between corporate bureaucracy and track-tested intuition. Shelby, a former racer who grokked the chaotic reality of performance firsthand, had little patience for theoretical approaches and paper prototypes. His driver, Ken Miles, insisted, “We’re lighter, we’re faster, and if that don’t work, we’re nastier,” embodying an aggressive disdain for theoretical assurances. Together, they put real-world experimentation above corporate caution, risking catastrophic failure for the chance at genuine victory.
Contrast Shelby’s ruthless practicality with Ford’s executives; comfortably insulated by meticulous plans and exhaustive simulations. Henry Ford II’s fixation on detailed, risk-free validation reveals a corporate addiction to illusory certainty — a false security born from avoiding real-world chaos. Shelby’s response is simple but revolutionary: confront uncertainty directly, testing relentlessly in real race conditions where genuine insights are won.
In my own career, I fallen prey to the allure of over-planned and carefully crafted roadmaps, naively believing that preparation alone would ensure success. Repeatedly humbled by projects that crashed spectacularly upon first contact with real-world users, I learned that reality violently dismantles even the most beautiful theories. A CTO friend, notorious for pushing teams to “test in production,” subscribes to a sobering, informed truth: No lab or staging environment truly replicates the brutal honesty of real-world use. Yes, engineers balked. But the harsh feedback from actual customers consistently exposed hidden flaws no controlled environment ever could.
Today’s product teams, seduced by the reassuring fiction of internal metrics — sprint velocity, completion checklists, bowling charts — fall prey to Goodhart’s Law, mistaking the metrics for meaningful outcomes. These measures become a comfort, like neatly arranged traffic cones in an empty parking lot, eventually obscuring the challenge of facing real traffic.
Shelby’s relentless pragmatism mirrors Formula 1’s brutal, data-driven approach: relentless testing and continuous refinement under the unforgiving pressures of actual racing conditions. Modern F1 teams rely heavily on precise data analytics tracking real-world variables — unpredictable weather shifts, mechanical failures, driver fatigue, or momentary lapses — which never neatly appear within the carefully controlled parameters of a simulation. F1’s obsession with data isn’t about eliminating uncertainty but about harnessing it, adapting swiftly as chaos inevitably unfolds. Authentic innovation emerges not from avoiding these unknowns, but from deliberately confronting them head-on. Shelby understood this: authentic innovation emerges precisely when confronted with chaos.
So how do product teams move beyond planning’s seductive illusion?
- Run Incremental Real-World Experiments: Expose products to actual customer environments. Genuine victories occur in the market, not isolated labs.
- Take Calculated Risks: Embrace on-track failures. Teams must accept temporary setbacks to uncover insights invisible in staged environments.
- Demand Genuine Impact: Pursue measurable customer outcomes — real satisfaction, market growth — not artificial internal benchmarks. Chase wins, not wind-tunnel data.
- Build Channels for Real Feedback: Equip teams to adapt rapidly. Like Miles tweaking the GT40 mid-race to exploit real-time opportunities.
Shelby understood something: Genuine success isn’t about raw speed — it’s mastering the art of when to brake, when to throttle, and precisely when to strike that is learned in the chaos of competition. This uncomfortable truth applies directly to product development, where perfect plans crumble the moment they collide with messy, unpredictable reality.
Subscribe to my Substack to get the latest articles: https://garyarlen.substack.com/